Uri Geller bent my classroom: a parable of bad science in education
'Guess where this has been?' |
I met
Uri Geller once. You may know him as the Israeli illusionist and magic
man who claims, among other things, that aliens visited him when he was a boy
and gave him the world-changing ability to...bend spoons. No, I don’t know what
they aliens were playing at either. Bending spoons doesn’t stand high on my
wish list of superpowers, but I expect it’s jolly important to the fate of
humanity. Anyway. Uri Geller makes a living bending spoons, and telling people
he can bend spoons, which means he must hang out with a lot of fairly stupid
people,. He was a chum of Michael Jackson, you know. Isn’t that nice? The King
of Crawl and Magneto, Master of Cutlery and condiments. What a pair. Mankind’s
only hope.
So I met
him. I was running a restaurant (TGI Fridays, for my sins) in London, Piccadilly Circus, and Mr Geller was
in town, on a tour bending spoons. (Jesus Christ, I feel like I’m writing this
about the Victorian Music Halls- ‘Mr Geller the Israelite will bend metal
paraphernalia to his will using electromagnetic mesmerism’ etc) He was dining
right in the centre of an already indiscreet restaurant, and we had clocked him
the moment he walked in. There aren’t many spoon benders, to be fair.
At the
end of the meal, he jumped up (I am not making this up- he leapt up like I was
in a cutlery set. I feared for my belt –buckle) and grabbed me by the wrist.
‘Do you
know who I am?’ he said. He was staring at me like I had murdered his family.
He had presence, I’ll give him that.
‘Of
course, Mr Geller,’ I said, big smoothie. ‘You're very well known.’ It’s odd
speaking to a famous person who demands to be recognised. More from pity than anything else I wanted to put him at his celebrity ease. Plus he frightened
me.
‘Do you
know what I do?’
‘What
apart from lie to people and hide bent spoons up your arse?’ is what I wanted
to say. But because I wanted to enjoy a continued career in the upper end of the
casual dining market, I demurred and flattered his withered ego.
‘I
believe I do,’ I compromised.
‘Would
you like me to show your staff something amazing?’ he said. In truth, I would
have. Instead, I was worried it was going to involve a spoon. But I nodded.
‘Gather
them round,’ he said, ‘And get me a fork.’ Curve ball.
As my staff were all carnies and out-of-work showbiz types, the chance of a bit of star
f*cking and spectacle was irresistible. Try and get them to sing happy birthday
to a child and they vanished like rats in a spotlight. Now, they clumped like iron
filings around a magnet. Now the next bit is important. I went to the kitchen
and fetched a fresh fork from the dishwasher, which is to say I had to clean it
again before I took it out. I got the fork. One of our forks. That bit is important.
I
brought the fork to him and we crowded round like mobsters round Brando in Guys
and Dolls. Geller took my fork in one hand, and lightly placed two fingers in a
benediction on to its throat. He rubbed them back and forth like a cautious DJ,
everyone’s eyes trained on the unremarkable utensil, inches away.
And the
fork started to bend.
Slowly, but visibly. And it- at least it seemed- to carry
on bending after he took his fingers from it. Reader, he bent the fork. Looking
pleased, he smiled a smile that nature never made, and passed the fork to
me. Curved, the neck was as stiff as steel, not hot. I held it like it was made
of Kryptonite, or moonbeams.
‘Thank
you!’ he said. ‘A souvenir!’ He left. I gave the fork to a waiter, who wore it
on his braces for years afterwards.
Of
course you may not be amazed to learn that Geller was doing shows in London
that week. Who better to amaze than waiters in one of the West End’s most
fertile gardens of pre-theatre-goers and the easily entertained? I knew a
cunning nightclub manager who would ride in taxis, talk up the club, tip big,
and give free passes to the cabbie. These people are key advertisers, and I
suppose so were we. I imagine many customers heard that Big Chief Uri had
parked his wagon in town with much big medicine.
This
story illustrates how we can be misled from reason and the experience of our senses. I do not for one second
believe that aliens from space travelled light years across the cosmos to
impart a lonely Israeli boy with absolute mastery over the architecture of the
tines of tableware. I don’t believe that the fork bent, or appeared to bend in
any way other than the perfectly rational. I am well aware that he is a
shuffling huckster, albeit a harmless one. But in that one odd moment, the
unavailability of a sensible explanation left one with the palpable sense that
something mysterious and inexplicable had occurred. In short, in the absence of
a concrete explanation, the mind raced to alternatives more fantastic.
Which is exactly how I feel whenever I read educational research that suggests something idiotic, like all children learn better in horseshoes or hedgehogs or whatever. If someone tells you they can bend spoons in the classroom, ask them what other gifts the aliens gave them.
Read the book "Uri Geller: Mystic or Magician" in which a well-renowned journalist did some SERIOUS research into his background. There is NO mention of aliens - never has been. That aside, thank goodness for rational thinkers like yourself who can watch something happen, dismiss it, and stick doggedly to the "spoon up the arse" theory. You should get yourself published in an academinc, peer-reviewed scientific journal. :-)
ReplyDelete